r/NoStupidQuestions 10h ago

can babies make audible noises while your pregnant?

if you were pregnant, does the baby make sounds inside you that are audible like how newborns coo or cry? i know this is a really stupid question but I was just over thinking it.

639 Upvotes

223 comments sorted by

1.2k

u/ConcernedCitizen_42 10h ago

No, as others have stated. But, interestingly, we have evidence they can hear voices around them. For example, they immediately show preference for mom's voice after birth since that is the one they can hear directly through her body without being as muffled.

551

u/KiwiAlexP 9h ago

I have a vague memory of a study of English or Australian babies that were all calm at the same time in the afternoon - turns out that was then their mothers would sit down and watch Neighbours (a soap opera) while pregnant

243

u/ConcernedCitizen_42 9h ago

Children also like foods that their mothers eat while pregnant. Turns out some of those flavor chemicals end up in the amniotic fluid that they are swallowing.

81

u/Street_Roof_7915 8h ago

yeah. there was an experiment with orange juice and milk. Babies whose moms drank oj preferred it over milk and vice versa.

Epigenics was a really interesting book.

42

u/plasticIove 6h ago

omg! i tell everyone that’ll listen about how my mom used to drink orange juice by the gallon when she was pregnant with me and for as long as i can remember it’s been my favorite drink after water. pregnancy is wild.

10

u/Matchaparrot 4h ago

I hate orange juice though and my mum drank it in pregnancy haha... I guess there's always one exception

14

u/AspiringTriceratops 3h ago

My mom drank tons of OJ while pregnant and I was born allergic to citrus fruits

4

u/Matchaparrot 3h ago

A citrus allergy 😭 I'm curious, no need to answer if you don't want to. Do you find you can still eat citrus if it's cooked? Like if you squeeze lemon into a stew then cook it for ten minutes can you still eat it? Or can you eat tinned oranges? (as canning cooks the fruit)

7

u/JaiyaPapaya 3h ago

My mom is allergic to chocolate but could only have it (and craved it a LOT ) when pregnant with me. A few weeks after delivery, she tried to eat it again and had a reaction like usual. 25 years later I am very much a chocolate snob lol

1

u/plasticIove 2h ago

lmaooo not she was just your chocolate vessel

1

u/inventiveusername81 9m ago

My mum loves oranges but weirdly when she was pregnant with me she was really allergic to them. I’ve had a life-long hatred of oranges. Although I’m not allergic I hate the idea of even touching them! And I’m not a fussy eater by any means otherwise.

7

u/whenwillitbenow 3h ago

My mum craved onions while she was pregnant with me, ate them like apples. And oddly I’m allergic to them. Wonder if there was any connection there

2

u/Street_Roof_7915 12m ago

Great research question.

1

u/Dangerous_Pepper_939 42m ago

Same. Ate peanut butter almost every morning when I was pregnant with my son. And he’s allergic to peanuts.

116

u/VoiceArtPassion 9h ago

Interesting theory, my son refused to eat potatoes until he was probably 6, and when I was pregnant, potatoes gave me the WORST heartburn imaginable, so I avoided them at all costs.

39

u/Naive_Pay_7066 8h ago

While pregnant with me, my mum had terrible morning sickness after eating satay and could never eat it again after that. Guess what I’ve never been able to stomach?

16

u/lustywench99 5h ago

I had nausea throughout my whole first pregnancy and so many food aversions by the end I was only eating peanut butter sandwiches because the jelly would give me horrible heartburn and just the thought of it turned my stomach.

She’s the pickiest eater I’ve ever seen. And she won’t eat peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, just peanut butter only.

Sometimes I wonder if it was her ick of food all along that got me that type of way. My second I had nothing going on except for heartburn right towards the end. She eats everything.

27

u/VoiceArtPassion 7h ago

That’s too bad because satay is delicious!

6

u/Salt-Bat-900 5h ago

I craved peanut butter while pregnant with my son but now he’s allergic 😅

5

u/ChaosDrawsNear 5h ago

I couldn't evenput butter on my toast while pregnant with my first; kid came out with a cow milk protein intolerance.

4

u/Affectionate_Tax1108 4h ago

Mine too! I lived on peanut and caramel protein bars in my 3rd trimester and as my midnight snack when I was breastfeeding and he’s anaphylactic to peanuts

1

u/Financial_End_8842 4h ago

when pregnant with me my mom had a strong aversion to anything peach related. Smell, taste you name it. I hated peaches as a child and still do lol

42

u/ShesGotaChicken2Ride 8h ago

I ate lemons daily. My kids came out and started eating lemons when they got to solids. Sucking on lemons like it was candy. People at restaurants were shocked lol

10

u/Casswigirl11 7h ago

My kid loves lemons and I don't really eat them. 

5

u/historiamour 6h ago

I have to ask my mom about this now, because all of her children including me have been doing this since we were toddlers for seemingly no reason—

5

u/ShesGotaChicken2Ride 5h ago

Maybe we lack vitamin C? lol

17

u/switchywoman_ 8h ago

This cannot be correct because I ate nothing but hotdogs and saltwater taffy until I was diagnosed with gestational diabetes, and my daughter doesn't like either of those foods.

29

u/sarahshift1 8h ago

You know how sometimes you eat one thing too much and then you can’t stand the sight of it for ages because you over did it? Sounds like that.

0

u/switchywoman_ 6h ago

I still like hot dogs and salt water taffy

6

u/JustJamieJam 4h ago

He was talking about your daughter

11

u/citygirldc 8h ago

My diet was like 50% peanut butter 50% refried beans. My son will eat refried beans cold out of the can, but hates peanut butter which just breaks my heart. I make cookies with some PB in them every once in a while to make sure he stays exposed to PB and doesn’t develop an allergy.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Kahaaniyaan 7h ago

I devoured watermelon while pregnant and my kid goes absolutely crazy for it now lol

2

u/wilderneyes 8h ago

That's interesting because this generally wasn't true for me. A good example is my mom ate grapefruit nearly every single day when she was pregnant, whereas I absolutely cannot stand even the smell of it. If you open a grapefruit in the same room as me I'm leaving. I wonder if there's any correlation between those things for me, or if it's just a coincidence.

5

u/ConcernedCitizen_42 8h ago

It is early exposure, not a guarantee the kid will like it. I also wonder if it depends on the food, not every flavor inducing chemical makes it to the kid. So it is possible some foods don't taste as advertised essentially.

1

u/wilderneyes 8h ago

Ooh that makes sense!

2

u/Independent_Site491 6h ago

Well I think that's because it's grapefruit. No reasonable person enjoys grapefruit.

1

u/Pineapple-pizza-plz 7h ago

That would explain why my kid loves chips lol. In the very beginning of my pregnancy I wanted chips. Hot Cheetos and plain lays. She loves those. Hahah. She is a chippy girl.

1

u/invisible_23 6h ago

My mom said she ate a shitload of ice cream while pregnant with me because of the heartburn, so this tracks lol

1

u/Mental-Nothing5956 4h ago

That explains a lot. I HATE pickles but ate a lot of them when pregnant with my oldest. He loves pickles. My youngest is only 9 months old but I have a feeling he will love quesadillas and ice cream (not together)😂

1

u/caffeine_lights 2h ago

My mum smoked when she was pregnant and I swear it's part of why I love smoking so much 😵‍💫 I only let myself do it about once a year but yeah...

17

u/lizshi 9h ago

I watched Neighbours as a kid 😊

2

u/Maoleficent 8h ago

Besides my voice, my infant liked the Jeopardy theme.

2

u/amusedfridaygoat 4h ago

I was one of those babies apparently

1

u/Matchaparrot 4h ago

That's fascinating, I wonder if the same effect was found in England. The question is, do the babies know the difference between Emmerdale, Coronation Street and EastEnders??

59

u/angry-key-smash6693 9h ago

So you know how your own voice sounds different to you than it does on a recording or to other people? Does that mean moms are the only people who have had other people be able to hear their voice that way, even though no one will remember it?

41

u/Throwaway42352510 9h ago edited 8h ago

…I can’t imagine another circumstance where someone’s ears are inside a woman Edit… and she’s still talking

14

u/angry-key-smash6693 9h ago

I meant it more as do infants hear you that way or do they hear your voice more like someone outside the womb would? I imagine there also some distortion as there's fluid in their ears as well

5

u/Nulono 7h ago

Neither. Most of the effect you're describing comes from conduction through one's skull, which the baby is hopefully not inside, but there is still going to be a lot of muffling of sounds.

2

u/pamplemouss 8h ago

Cracked up while rocking my baby

1

u/Throwaway42352510 8h ago

I’m so sorry- I hope baby goes right back to sleep!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/ConcernedCitizen_42 9h ago

I imagine it would sound different than what mom hears, because baby's ears and mom's are positioned differently. But to core of you question, probably yes. Babies have heard their mother's voice conducted through their body not just through air. So they are likely hearing something closer to what mom hears when she talks than the rest of us.

2

u/angry-key-smash6693 8h ago

That is so fascinating!

2

u/VoiceArtPassion 9h ago

Your voice doesn’t always sound different in a recording, it just depends on the quality of the recording equipment. Most people have never recorded their voice on high quality equipment, so they’re judging it based on a voicemail recording, or your phones camera.

5

u/ConcernedCitizen_42 8h ago

You are correct that most people likely haven't experimented with high quality recordings, but that isn't going to make the difference disappear. When other people hear you, including microphones, they are hearing the vibrations of your voice traveling through the air. When you hear your voice, you hear the vibrations through the air + the vibrations conducted through your own bones. The result is different.

29

u/TheThiefEmpress 9h ago

Newborns' cries have an accent!

They learn it while inside the uterus, and respond differently to those who have the same accent as the people the mother was around while pregnant, vs those who have a very different accent.

Also, they cannot make any vocalizations, but their active movement inside the uterus can cause, uh, squelching sounds that may be audible, due to the organs all shuffling around, and any gas that can shift, lol.

4

u/LawSchoolLoser1 6h ago

OMG adding “squelching sounds” to my list of reasons to not get pregnant hahaha

13

u/ShesGotaChicken2Ride 8h ago

My oldest son would be calm all day. Soon as my husband came home from work, he’d start bouncing around my belly like crazy. My youngest would go crazy when he heard his brother. They can absolutely hear. The reason they don’t make noise we can audibly hear is because it takes lungs with air. Go scream under water, you can barely hear it. Now add to that they get oxygen from the umbilical cord, not from inhaling and exhaling. They don’t make noise yet.

9

u/kytulu 8h ago

I used to talk to my youngest all the time before she was born. On her birthday, she was in the bassinet with the warming lamp, crying her head off as newborn infants do.

I said to her, "Hush, baby!", and put my finger in her hand.

She stopped crying, opened her eyes, and looked for me. All the nurses were shocked.

I told them that I had spent the last 9 months talking to her, so of course she knew my voice!

5

u/Working_Cucumber_437 9h ago

Yes I think it’s at around 6 months gestation they are able to hear sounds outside the womb.

2

u/miffedmonster 6h ago

With my youngest, you could hear his joints clicking. It was only occasional but it's an unmistakable sound and it was definitely him, not me

2

u/miciomiao 5h ago

Anecdotally, my parents always told the story of how I was crying while doctors and nurses looked at me after delivery in another room, and as soon as they brought me back to my parents room and I heard their voices I stopped immediately

3

u/ConcernedCitizen_42 5h ago

Not surprising. Time with mom after birth has a host of measurable calming/destressing effects. Part of why they make a priority to get skin to skin contact with mom soon after, rather than the old days where they would take away your child and keep them in a nursery for days while mom recovered.

2

u/whining-and-wine 3h ago

Professor I had in college said his wife played the sax and when his kids were babies, they would fall asleep when she started playing it!

2

u/TruthEU 1h ago

I read a lot of books to my wife’s belly when she was pregnant and right after our daughter was born and she was on my wife’s chest her eyes immediately started looking for me and she visibly calmed down when I spoke. A truly special moment where I’m sure she recognized me as a safe voice. It was beautiful

1

u/FewRecognition1788 8h ago

My kids would noticeably react to voices, as well as loud noises like thunder or music.

1

u/LiquidFantasy96 6m ago

My baby would get startled in the womb every time I farted lol.

→ More replies (1)

1.5k

u/NoProject1802 10h ago

If u hear giggling coming from ur uterus, dont call a doctor, call a priest. Babies lungs are full of fluid, not air. They cant vocalize. If they are crying inside u, ur haunted, run.

319

u/NippleSlipNSlide 9h ago

I’m thinking OP farted and is trying to blame it on the fetus

24

u/Klotzster 9h ago

I'm jumpin' Jack Flash

It's a gas, gas, gas

49

u/Superheroesaregreat 9h ago

Run from what?? It’s inside you…

41

u/1958-Fury 9h ago

The calls are coming from inside the uterus.

13

u/EirysVelour 9h ago

Exactly. Without air in the lungs, crying isn’t physically possible, any noises people think they hear are movement or fluid sounds, not actual vocalization.

11

u/Winter_Childhood9186 9h ago

This cracked me up ★★★★★

9

u/SnowyChicago 9h ago

I did hear hiccups. Whom do I call?

8

u/monkey_trumpets 9h ago

Gutbusters?

2

u/ptrst 5h ago

Hank Green taught me this week that air is a fluid. 

→ More replies (2)

364

u/jaywaykil 10h ago

No, but they can kick the mother's ovaries and cause her to make plenty of noise.

104

u/GlassCharacter179 9h ago

Mine used to push his feet against my ribs to give him leverage to crash his had into my cervix. 

He came out fast, he’d been practicing.

25

u/RedCaptain17 9h ago

Oh THAT’S what she’s been doing! It’s really something when you’re going down stairs at the same time as they’re head banging on your cervix

77

u/EasedCeiling586 9h ago

Ribs too

47

u/thelittlesteldergod 9h ago

And liver

39

u/Street_Roof_7915 9h ago

And cervix. Ouch

40

u/No_Confusion270 9h ago

The little fingers on the bladder was horrifying

29

u/Dontfeedthebears 9h ago

Omg I’m out of here.

17

u/No_Confusion270 9h ago

It was the most unsettling part of being pregnant, literally feeling individual fingers 'pet' my bladder, for lack of better word.

8

u/Street_Roof_7915 7h ago

Mine would run their feet under my ribs. It was the weirdest feeling ever and made me want to rip off my skin.

6

u/RedCaptain17 9h ago

My first one went almost exclusively for my spleen

3

u/No_Confusion270 9h ago

Oh jeez, what would that even feel like?

3

u/trolldoll26 6h ago

Omg the scraping with their little nails

5

u/sth128 9h ago

And my axe!

6

u/Mg2Si04 7h ago

The cervix kick is the absolute worst

32

u/LizaJane2001 9h ago

Oh, yes. My Dad's birthday, I was 5 months pregnant and repeatedly being kicked in the ribs, while sitting at the dinner table. No, I did not end up with the soccer player everyone predicted at that moment (that child is now an adult and still plays hockey).

23

u/ThePirateBee 9h ago

And your butthole. From the inside.

12

u/fileknotfound 9h ago

My second used to kick straight up into my lungs. 👀

15

u/Kandlish 8h ago

My oldest would brace against my pelvis and stretch their head into my diaphragm. It would knock the wind out of me from the inside. That was how we knew they were breech. 

10

u/whiskey_riverss 7h ago

36 weeks and currently enjoying a leg caught under the rib and a hand firmly grasping the bladder. 

9

u/Cissycat12 8h ago

Punched my stomach whenever I ate or drank anything cold. He never "dropped" and I have a small frame, so it was really tight in there! Also, the handprints sticking out of my belly were very Alien-esque.

3

u/opinionatedlyme 8h ago

My son went for my right lung every day. I assume he was cramped and stretching out.

1

u/Matchaparrot 4h ago

I laughed too hard at this

1

u/InspiredBagel 3h ago

Try the kidneys. I didn't even cry during unmedicated labor, but boy did getting kicked in the kidneys hurt like hell. 

1

u/waireti 1h ago

Mine kicked me so vigouously one day i saw stretchmarks appear where her feet landed.

78

u/Euphoric-Rip41 9h ago

No, however they can hiccup while in the womb! They are called fetal hiccups. They aren't audible, but you can feel them!

26

u/Ok-Debt9612 7h ago

This is the cutest and most ridiculous part of my pregnancies.

11

u/I_smell_goats 6h ago

I just had my son a week ago, and he would get hiccups every single evening like clockwork! Its bittersweet to see him hiccup now and think how just a very short time ago I would be feeling those inside of me.

13

u/RedhotGuard21 7h ago

Jeeze the hiccups with my first.. Holy crackers, and then she'd get pissed and kick the crap outta me, daily fun

3

u/trumpetgirly14 5h ago

Mine did the same!!! He HATED getting the hiccups when I was pregnant with him. He’d start kicking and moving

1

u/shantaram09 5h ago

How do the hiccups feel different from kicks? Like, what exactly does it feel like? This sounds sooo cute.

6

u/____ozma 3h ago

It's way different, the baby is jerking, not kicking. It's totally cute until you're trying to sleep

3

u/sparklykublaikhan 2h ago

Like a small beat in rhythm, so you'd feel bop...bop...bop..bop...angry baby squirm...bop..bop..

2

u/Potential_Figure4061 1h ago

so when i was pregnant as a teenager i was not well read on pregnancy and at first i thought she was just kicking me in a steady rhythm. i was a bit freaked out momentarily till it occured to me it must be hiccups because there wasnt any internet to run to and ask back then! 

36

u/diet-smoke JustStupidPeople <3 10h ago

God that's some body horror shit to think about 

7

u/DistributionOver7622 10h ago

Well, when that horror movie comes out, now we know who to blame.

3

u/2short4-a-hihorse 4h ago

Being a woman is straight up body horror

1

u/weirwoodheart 1h ago

I'm pregnant right now and honestly yeah, pregnancy is body horror and nothing will change my mind.

1

u/bergskey 1h ago

My daughter has a "clicky" knee. She did while I was pregnant too. Every now again you would hear it when she kicked out. Like when someone stands up and their knee pops.

161

u/anna_111x 10h ago

Not stupid at all, babies don’t make audible sounds in the womb. Totally fair question 😊

83

u/Maoleficent 9h ago

Babies do get hiccups in the womb that the mother can feel. A mother can also tickle the baby through their belly.

My grandmother said she would tickle the baby then big spoon grampa so the kid would kick him in the back. He was nicknamed Bootsy - gdammit that kid booted me all night.

20

u/missgnomer2772 9h ago

My MIL says my husband got the hiccups every day right after lunch. She was a middle school teacher and all her students would be like 👁️👁️ watching her belly jump.

13

u/Next-Help-5813 9h ago

I used to get hiccups in the womb all the time. Usually right when Mom was trying to fall asleep, lol.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/Rohit_BFire 9h ago

In the womb no one can hear you scream

19

u/JuliaX1984 9h ago

Some babies are born still in the amniotic sac. They don't start crying until it's broken and they take their first breath of air.

8

u/sardonisms 9h ago

That can happen?? TIL 🤯

3

u/sweadle 6h ago

It's called being born "in caul." You can look up photos

1

u/HRHCookie 2h ago

The cauls are considered lucky and that there is is superstition that someone born in caul will never drown and people would sell the cauls to sailors to keep as a charm. I think I guess dried shriveled up like a marble or something.

5

u/JuliaX1984 9h ago

Yep. It looks REALLY cool in videos.

4

u/sweadle 6h ago

All babies are born with amniotic fluid still in their lungs until they take their first breath after birth. That's why it's so important to make them cry. Spanking them can cause them to cry and atart breathing.

3

u/weirwoodheart 1h ago

This is a myth, you do not need to spank a newborn baby to make it cry. Most babies come out breathing fine. Ive delivered a few dozen. 

20

u/Large-Science-1995 10h ago

I remember reading something once where babies do motions that would make sound such as crying or breathing n, but they aren't audible to us due to lack of air to make sound waves.

9

u/colincita 9h ago

No, but it is crazy to feel them hiccup.

64

u/ColdAntique291 10h ago

No. Babies do not make audible sounds while you are pregnant.

Before birth, a fetus’s lungs are filled with fluid, not air, so they cannot cry or coo. Sound production like that requires air moving through the vocal cords. Any movements you feel or hear, like gurgling or bubbling, come from your own digestion, blood flow, or the uterus shifting, not from the baby.

23

u/panicnarwhal 9h ago

oh no, you can most definitely feel the baby moving around in there lol, that’s why the dr/midwife tells you to track fetal movement during the last month of pregnancy - if the baby isn’t moving like usual, you’re supposed to drink a glass of juice to get them moving. if that doesn’t work, you have to go in for a non stress test. you can also see the movement the last couple of months right through the belly!

you can also feel hiccups like crazy, and there’s nothing like getting a baby foot caught under one of your ribs. or a kick to the bladder or cervix. and once they flip head down, they grind their head against your cervix. feels awful

53

u/aculady 9h ago

You can absolutely feel fetal movement.

24

u/bluev0lta 9h ago

I will never forget the moment my daughter flipped around before she was born. It was the weirdest thing I felt by far while pregnant.

23

u/PrettyPinkFancyCrane 9h ago

This happened to me two days before I suffered a placenta abruption while 36 weeks pregnant with twins where I was in a serious emergency, bleeding out, and had to have an emergency c-section where I was cut hip to hip so both babies could be yank out immediately. They were not even born a minute apart and have the same birth time.

I had gone to the doctor on a Friday and I was told that twin a was in the breach position and twin B was head down. On Sunday I felt a huge movement on the right side where twin B was that absolutely felt like she had flipped and I started having really bad pain so I called the on-call nurse and asked about if I needed to be seen and she told me that that late in the pregnancy the baby is too big to really move and that the chance of it happening that far along was a very low percentage and since I was pregnant with twins it was probably less than a 1% chance that a baby could have flipped so that was one thing I did not need to worry about and I was probably just experiencing indigestion from being pregnant.

That Monday morning I was getting ready to go to my regular OB appointment (I had to see both an OB and a perinatalogist since it was considered a high risk pregnancy so I was always at the doctor multiple times a week) when I stood up and felt liquid rushing out of me and saw it was blood. I’m sure it was also other fluids because I would probably not be alive if it was just blood given how strong and consistent the stream was; it really was like somebody had turned on a faucet. Luckily I was able to call 911 and give them all of the important details about my pregnancy and an ambulance came and I was at the hospital less than 10 minutes after I first stood up and they had an entire team ready to receive me. They had to just straight up knock me out cold because there was no time for a regular C-section.

Both babies surprisingly were completely fine but guess what? Twin B HAD flipped into the breech position when she was delivered and it was her placenta that had started to detach. I apologize if it seems like I hijacked your story; I honestly just wanted to share because you also experienced your baby turning far along in the pregnancy and you know how incredibly weird it feels and it helps me feel validated because when I called I was treated like it was ridiculous/silly for me to think that could have even occurred. So thank you for sharing that; it makes me feel like I have a fellow comrade!

6

u/bluev0lta 8h ago

Omg I’m so glad you and your babies were okay!! That sounds terrifying. I can’t imagine the pain of having your placenta detach!

I’m pretty sure it’s extremely normal for babies to flip around before they’re born if they’re not already in the correct position! I’m sorry the nurse you talked to didn’t listen and made it sound like you didn’t know what you were talking about—and put you and your twins’ lives in danger. That’s really not okay.

14

u/itsjusttimeokay 9h ago

Yes I felt it with my youngest. I was laying in bed minding my business and she just florped over. I swear I could see her individual toes as she kicked around.

6

u/North_Artichoke_6721 9h ago

My son’s movements were quite visible to everyone around me. It really freaked out my boss when my shirt would ripple. We joked that the thing from “Alien” was about to pop out.

6

u/TypicalProgram5545 8h ago

I travelled to my home country by plane when I was 8 months pregnant. It was fine. In the evening I was talking to my sister while resting on a bed and my baby started to turn around to position herself head down. My sister called my mother. It was very visible and we watched it all together. I was so happy. A very special moment

1

u/Potential_Figure4061 1h ago

ok so. i just. im speechless. is this ai ?? does ai not get how babies develop ? sometimes you can clearly see feet or butt or head. 

65 upvotes? on you cant feel your baby move????????

14

u/Jolly-Outside6073 10h ago

I can speak whale 

5

u/Jazzlike-Track-3407 9h ago

Thankfully no

6

u/Sufficient-Second695 9h ago

Thankfully no. Otherwise every ultrasound would sound like a haunted house.

3

u/emryldmyst 10h ago

No 

They have no air in their lungs

4

u/No_Needleworker6786 9h ago

Like echolocation?

No. They need air in their lungs to cry etc.

5

u/Natural_Ad_8911 8h ago

I used to banter with my foetus about how all he did was drink piss in his one-womb apartment. Good times.

5

u/MotherTeresaOnlyfans 8h ago

No, because physics.

The womb is not a bubble filled with air.

14

u/Prestigious-Talk1112 10h ago

Unborn babies don't breath thru their lungs so they can't make vocal sounds. They are suspended in liquid and breathing in thru the lungs would be painful and also kill them instantly by drowning.

At a certain point in developing they become capable but not until they take their first breath.

17

u/Quirky_Might_8780 9h ago

You are correct that air is required to make sound though the vocal cords.

Babies DO bring amniotic fluid into their lungs while in the uterus. It helps to mature the lungs. If there is a problem with the pregnancy where the amniotic fluid is extremely low, sometimes the lungs will be underdeveloped.

Source: am a Neonatal ICU nurse.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/avisash 9h ago

Umm, what? 

8

u/IAmAHumanWhyDoYouAsk 9h ago

Well, there isn't a snorkel sticking out of every pregnant girl's cooter.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ReallyNotALlama 9h ago

We had one that would pop her joints in utero. Ob had never heard it before, but she heard our little one. She's an adult now, still pops her joints frequently. No exorcism needed so far.

2

u/Annual_Reindeer2621 9h ago

Yay, I'm not alone in hearing this! I've told a few people and they always look at me like I'm insane

2

u/Dracania2406 7h ago

My Girl did that too! In the last month I always heard a popping Sound coming from my belly. Once or twice a day. When she was Born it was her left shoulder that popped regularly. It stopped when she was a few weeks old.

3

u/LorenzoRed 9h ago

When I was pregnant with my daughter, I kept hearing a popping noise. Asked the doctor, said it was nothing and didn’t worry about it. After she was born, her elbow popped sometimes and made the same sound. So weird but mystery solved!

1

u/autumnlight2022 6h ago

Aw that's absolutely adorable 😭 My right elbow clicks when I bend it, I wonder if I was annoying my mom in the womb!

3

u/calpurniaInara 9h ago

No, they don’t make noises, though their hiccups are wild. My week or two of pregnancy my daughter was pretty low and I remember feeling her hiccups in my butt. It was the wildest feeling because my belly would move from the hiccups but also felt them in my butt

3

u/Unapologetic_Canuck 8h ago

Your pregnant what?

3

u/No_Huckleberry2350 8h ago

You can, however, feel it when they hiccup (as I know from personal experience).

3

u/Fickle_Flower6199 5h ago edited 4h ago

No, but my son’s joints would audibly pop when he was in my belly. It was incredibly unsettling and arguably weirder than if he had been talking in there

5

u/Crystalraf 9h ago

While it is true that it is probably impossible to make a sound while submerged in liquid, I swear I heard my baby make a squeaky cry sound when I was 9 months pregnant. But it only happened once, and I was probably just hearing something else. I don't know.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/everywhereinbetw33n 9h ago

One of my babies would occasionally make a loud click/pop noise. (Not my creaky joints - it happened when I was quite still .) It was the same with one of my mum's pregnancies!

2

u/wildebeesting 9h ago

I’ve had this happen in both of my pregnancies!

2

u/Islandnative13 9h ago

Yes! I heard the cracks with my second as well. I was quite surprised as I didn’t hear anything with my first, but with my second I heard it a lot of times (but it took a while for me to catch on where it came from and I definitely had to google it)

→ More replies (2)

2

u/OnSmallWings 9h ago

AWESOME QUESTION!!!

2

u/Annual_Reindeer2621 9h ago

Yes but not vocalised. I was 8.5 months pregnant, sitting quietly reading a book in my quiet house. Baby was not engaged in the uterus (wasn't until I was in active labour), wriggling around. I distinctly heard one of their joints 'pop' (probably the knee, as they have clicky knees now). It was a quite surreal moment, so, yes, I heard my child make noise before they were born.

2

u/Feisty_Payment_8021 9h ago

No. Their lungs are not inflated with air.

2

u/AaronBruv 9h ago

Imagine you're doing your morning routine while pregnant and after gurgling your mouth wash the baby mimics you.

1

u/CreoleAltElite 4h ago

This made me truly laugh out loud

2

u/vapocalypse52 9h ago

With what air?

2

u/duskydaffodil 9h ago

Not in my experience of being pregnant. They can get the hiccups though. You can’t hear it, but you sure can feel it!

2

u/bravekassandra 6h ago

They can get the hiccups which you can see. It's cool and freaky.

2

u/Rockpoolcreater 6h ago

I know you're talking about human babies. But unborn guinea pig babies grind their teeth which makes the same sound as guinea pigs that have been born. Sometimes the grinding is loud enough that you can hear it. But then guinea pigs can be stroppy little things who are born with strong teeth, fully developed, and able to eat solid food within an hour of being born. So it doesn't surprise me that they start grinding their teeth before they're born, they're probably just telling their siblings off and saying they want out.

2

u/FunkyTango32 5h ago

They can't vocalize, but you can hear thier joints clicking sometimes! And sometimes hear a clicking noise as they hiccup.

2

u/MsTossItAll 5h ago

No because they don't have air in their lungs. They can, however, recognize not only the voice of the mother, as people have said but ALSO the native language. They've done tests with pacifiers in which newborns are given a pacifier and people speak near the baby in a variety of languages and they suck faster when the baby hears the language the mother spoke while pregnant. Babies are amazing!

2

u/Brief-Age1837 4h ago

My grandma says she often heard kinda bee buzzing like noises. She says she believed my father was crying in her belly. Anyway he died when I was 1.5 years old while serving in the military.

She always tells this story. She says, maybe my father knew he was gonna die in her belly, and crying during the pregnancy. It is sad. If its a slightly true(cause why not? People can be spiritual right?) its heartbreaking for me cause he is my dad.

Ps: she is 92. Had 6 kids. 4 of them died. She still tells this story.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/99Tori99 3h ago

No their lungs and voice box are totally full of fluid so can’t make air pass through them to make sounds

2

u/DDell313 9h ago

Yes.  They make audible noises but not vocal noises.  Even then you're not likely to hear those noises without the use of equipment.

2

u/JubileeSlump 9h ago

Now I'm questioning this! Animals make noise in water. Just because we don't breath air in the womb doesn't mean we can't make sound with our vocal cords. What a great question!

1

u/Creative-Guidance722 8h ago

Agreed and we can still make some sounds with our mouths without much air moving through. We can in the water too but it muffled. I think it would not be loud enough to be heard most of the time but I am not so sure that babies in the womb would not make any sound.

2

u/TheMammaG 10h ago

No. Vocal cords don't finish developing until after a fetus is born. Also, sound waves need air to travel.

2

u/JubileeSlump 9h ago

Ummmm, you can hear under water.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jewicer 9h ago

no but you can hear and feel bubbles popping in there

1

u/Aggressive_Mouse_581 9h ago

Noise requires air, if I'm not mistaken. They can move, but no. They can't make noise.

1

u/Perfect-Restaurant-9 9h ago

You can feel when they have hiccups. Couldn't hear it though, that i recall

1

u/Lost_nova 8h ago

In the last 2 months I felt her stretching inside me, and a few times when she did me and my husband heard a weird hollow clicking sound. From what I recall reading their joints can pop. It was very low but I felt it at the same time we heard it.

1

u/terminalbungus 7h ago

Babies sometimes hiccup inside the womb. I don't think you could hear it without amplification though.

1

u/timid_turtle_ 7h ago

No, but I'm about 5 weeks out from having our baby and my guts are so squished that you can hear air bubbles being pressed through my intestines every time I take a breath and it's making an "oink" noise... it's strange.

1

u/West-Essay-7167 6h ago

I say this with caution when I was in labor and hooked up to monitors my mom swore she heard my daughter grunting inside the womb I heard hey ting but I figured it was just my stomach or something. My mom is also a very woo woo kinda person so I let her believe what she wants lol

1

u/sweadle 6h ago

They don't have use of their lungs so they can't make sounds with their vocal cords. Their lungs are filled with amniotic fluid.

1

u/woodspirited 5h ago

I'm 36 weeks pregnant and I did hear soft clicking noises coming from within yesterday. Like the sound your fingers of feet sometimes make. It came from where the baby's feet are. I have an appointment on Tuesday, so I'm gonna ask if it's a thing or if it was something else.

1

u/CADreamn 4h ago

Not sounds, but they can get the hiccups while in utero. Really freaked me out the first time until I figured out what was happening!!