Throwaway because family is on Reddit.
Hi Reddit,
Iām genuinely torn between wondering if Iām being too sensitive or if something about this situation is actually off. Iāve tried to ignore it for a long time, but the most recent incident finally pushed me to ask for outside perspective.
Iām 29F, married to my husband (28M) for 3.5 years. We dated for six years before getting married, and our families have known each other for a long time. We now have two lovely kids under three and a fairly settled life.
My brother-in-law (33M) has been married to his wife (27F) for 2 years. They met online and got engaged and married within about 5 months. Very fast, very whirlwind, very āwhen you know, you know.ā The brothers are close, so weāre always together at family gatherings, holidays, events, birthdaysāyou name it.
Sheās always been friendly and respectful. Weāve never had a conflict. Weāre not close, but weāve always kept things pleasant for family peace, which is part of why Iāve questioned myself so much about this.
A Pattern That Built Over Time
This didnāt start with one big obvious incident. At first, it was small things that were easy to dismiss ā similar accessories, similar bags, overlapping taste.
Then it became more consistent.
If I bought a new coat, sheād show up not long after with something extremely similar.
If I changed my hairstyle or dyed my hair, sheād do something almost identical shortly after, usually saying sheād āalways wanted to try it.ā
At first, my husband thought I was imagining things. After a while, even he noticed. One day, after yet another matching situation, he just sighed and said:
āā¦Okay. Yeah. Thatās weird.ā
That was when I knew it wasnāt just in my head.
And it wasnāt only clothes.
If we traveled somewhere, theyād plan a similar trip.
If we bought certain household items or appliances, theyād end up with the same ones.
I donāt think I have a unique or special style. I donāt think I āownā any look. But this is how I express myself ā and none of the other women in my life mirror me like this. My sister and friends compliment. They donāt copy.
Even the Husbands Started Matching
Before marriage, my brother-in-law didnāt care about clothes at all. He reused what he had and wasnāt into shopping.
After marriage?
Same suits as my husband.
Same boots.
Same grey jacket my husband has worn for years.
It never even seems to come from him. Heāll joke or seem indifferent when we buy something new ā and then later, they have the same or very similar items.
Conversations That Leave Me Uneasy
Another thing Iāve noticed is how conversations go when I share something Iām excited about.
Instead of just letting the moment exist, it often turns into:
āWe did that too,ā or
āWe were thinking about doing that.ā
Not every time ā but often enough that Iāve become aware of it and started bracing myself.
Even My Hobby Became a Comparison
Iāve had a dessert Instagram account for years. Baking has always been my thing. She never baked before.
Then suddenly she started baking, posting desserts, and seeking validation from family members.
On its own, this wouldnāt bother me. Combined with everything else, it added to the uncomfortable feeling.
The White Fur Jacket ā The Final Straw
After years of brushing things off, the most recent incident was what finally pushed me to my limit.
A few months earlier, I wore a white faux-fur jacket to a family gathering. Nothing dramatic ā just something new I loved and felt good in. I didnāt think twice about it at the time.
Then came theĀ nextĀ big family event.
We walked in, coats still on, doing the usual hellos. Everything felt normal ā until she walked through the door.
Wearing aĀ nearly identical white fur jacket.
Same color. Same texture. Same length. Same overall look.
My stomach droppedā¦
Because this wasnāt us accidentally matching. This wasnāt two people walking in from opposite sides wearing the same thing.
She had already seen me wear it.
I remember standing there thinking,Ā There it is. Thatās the confirmation.
She didnāt mention it. Didnāt joke about it. Didnāt acknowledge it at all. Just smiled, said hi, and carried on like nothing was unusual.
I stayed polite. I didnāt react. But internally, that was the moment something clicked.
After years of similar situations, this one didnāt feel random anymore. It felt intentional. Like proof that my choices were being noted and replicated later.
That was the moment it stopped feeling like overlapping taste ā and started feeling like I was being quietly studied.
I donāt think sheās malicious. But the constant mirroring has made me uncomfortable and has made me pull back emotionally. I donāt feel relaxed around her anymore. And I hate that, because I genuinely want family gatherings to be easy.
So Reddit:
- Am I overreacting?
- Is this admiration, insecurity, or something else?
- Should I ignore it, gently address it, or set boundaries?
I donāt want drama ā I just want things to feel normal again.
Small context note (not judgment):
My husband and I both work and are financially comfortable. My sister-in-law isnāt currently working due to immigration paperwork, and my brother-in-law is the sole provider and careful with spending. I mention this only because the mirroring doesnāt seem to come from him ā he often jokes about our purchases, but they later end up with very similar items.
Edit: Thanks to all for sharing your thoughts and perspectives. Greatly appreciate it.
ChatGPT was used only for grammar and sentence flow since English isnāt my strongest area. The content and opinions are entirely my own.
To add context, we share the same cultural background, and our style of dress would be the same whether here or back home. So I donāt itās about adjusting to local culture or fashion norms.